Understanding Justification in Wesleyan Theology

Dance of Divine Grace

In the grand ballroom of existence, where the music of eternity plays, there unfolds a dance of incomparable beauty and significance. This is no ordinary waltz, dear reader, but the very dance of salvation itself. And at its heart lies a concept both profound and transformative: justification.

Imagine, if you will, a dance floor stretching as far as the eye can see. At one end stands humanity, broken and out of step, yearning for harmony but unable to find the rhythm. At the other end stands God, the Master Choreographer, arms outstretched in an eternal invitation. Justification, in the Wesleyan understanding, is God’s initiative in this cosmic dance. It is the moment when the Divine takes the first step towards us, extending a hand of grace, offering to lead us in a dance we could never master on our own.

But this is no simple two-step. John Wesley, that indefatigable pursuer of holiness, understood that in this dance of redemption, both faith and works play crucial roles. Picture, if you can, faith as the moment we accept God’s outstretched hand, and works as the steps we take thereafter, guided by our divine partner. One without the other creates an incomplete picture – a dancer who accepts the invitation but refuses to move, or one who tries to dance without a partner’s guidance.

As we delve deeper into this Wesleyan understanding, let us approach with hearts open and minds engaged. For in grasping this concept, we do more than simply accumulate knowledge – we learn to dance with the Divine.

The Nature of Justification: A Heavenly Pardon

What, then, is the nature of this justification that sets the dance in motion? In Wesleyan thought, justification is nothing less than a heavenly pardon, a divine decree that transforms our very standing before God.

Consider for a moment the weight of guilt that so often burdens our steps. The missteps, the wrong turns, the times we’ve trampled on others or stumbled over our own feet. In human terms, these would disqualify us from any dance of significance. But in God’s grand ballroom, a miraculous transformation occurs.

The Apostle Paul, that master theologian of grace, puts it thus: “Therefore, since we have been justified through faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 5:1-2). Notice the present perfect tense – “have been justified.” This is not a future hope or a conditional offer, but a present reality for those who have accepted God’s invitation.

Wesley himself, with characteristic precision, defined justification as “that act of God the Father, whereby, for the sake of the propitiation made by the blood of his Son, he ‘showeth forth his righteousness (or mercy) by the remission of the sins that are past.'” Let us unpack this rich statement.

Firstly, justification is an act of God the Father. We do not justify ourselves any more than a novice dancer could declare themselves a master. It is God who takes the initiative, God who extends the invitation, God who declares us righteous.

Secondly, this justification comes at a cost – “the propitiation made by the blood of his Son.” Here we encounter the profound mystery of the cross, where divine justice and mercy meet in perfect harmony. The dance floor of grace is stained with the blood of Christ, a sobering reminder of the price paid for our participation.

Lastly, justification results in the “remission of the sins that are past.” Picture, if you will, a great ledger of all our missteps and mistakes. In the act of justification, God does not merely cross out these entries or balance them against good deeds. Instead, the entire ledger is wiped clean, replaced with Christ’s own perfect performance.

But let us be clear – this heavenly pardon is not a mere legal fiction, a divine sleight of hand that pretends we never sinned. Instead, it is a transformative reality that changes our very relationship with God. We are not merely acquitted criminals, but adopted children, invited to dance in the Father’s house.

The Necessity of Faith: The Open Arms of the Soul

If justification is God’s invitation to the dance, then faith is our response – the open arms of the soul reaching out to accept God’s extended hand. In Wesleyan thought, faith plays a crucial and indispensable role in the process of justification.

Consider the words of Paul in his letter to the Ephesians: “For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast” (Ephesians 2:8-9). Here we see the beautiful interplay of divine initiative and human response. Grace extends the invitation, faith accepts it.

Wesley, with characteristic clarity, stated, “Faith is the condition, and the only condition, of justification.” This might seem, at first glance, to contradict his emphasis on works. But let us delve deeper.

Imagine, if you will, a great power plant, humming with energy, cables stretching out across the land. This power plant represents God’s grace, ever-present and all-sufficient. The cables are the means by which this grace reaches us. But without a connection point, without a switch to complete the circuit, the power remains potential, not actual. Faith, in this analogy, is that switch. It doesn’t generate the power, it doesn’t lay the cables, but it completes the circuit, allowing God’s justifying grace to flow into our lives.

But what is this faith? It is not mere intellectual assent, not a cold acknowledgment of theological facts. No, the faith that justifies is a living, active trust. It is stepping onto the dance floor, placing our hand in God’s, and allowing Him to lead. It is believing not just that God can save, but that He will save – save me, save you, save us.

Yet even this faith is not our own achievement. Notice Paul’s words – “and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God.” Even our ability to respond, to open the arms of our soul, is a gift of grace. We do not initiate the dance, we merely accept the invitation.

This understanding of faith as the conduit of justification guards against two equal and opposite errors. On one hand, it prevents us from thinking we can earn our justification through good works or religious observances. We cannot impress God with our dance moves; we can only accept His offer to teach us. On the other hand, it prevents us from thinking that our response to God doesn’t matter, that we can be passive spectators in our own salvation. Faith may be a gift, but it is a gift we must unwrap and use.

The Role of Works: The Fruit of Justification

Having established faith as the conduit of justification, we must now turn our attention to a topic that has caused much confusion and controversy in Christian thought: the role of works. In the Wesleyan understanding, good works are not the cause of justification, but rather its evidence and fruit.

James, the practical apostle, puts it bluntly: “In the same way, faith by itself, if it is not accompanied by action, is dead” (James 2:17). At first glance, this might seem to contradict Paul’s emphasis on faith alone. But Wesley, with his characteristic theological acumen, saw no contradiction here, only a deeper truth.

Picture, if you will, an apple tree. The tree does not become an apple tree by producing apples. Rather, it produces apples because it is an apple tree. In the same way, we are not justified by our good works, but our justification, if genuine, will inevitably produce good works.

Wesley himself challenged his followers: “Faith alone is the condition of present salvation; but if good works do not follow, it is a sure proof that this faith is not genuine, living faith.” This is a sobering thought, is it not? It calls us to examine our faith, to look for its fruits in our lives.

But let us be clear – these works are not a burden, not a checklist to be completed to maintain our justified status. Rather, they are the natural outflow of a life transformed by grace. They are the dance steps that follow our acceptance of God’s invitation, the movements that express the music of grace playing in our hearts.

Think of a couple deeply in love. They do not perform acts of kindness for each other to create love, but because love already exists. Their actions are the evidence and expression of their love, not its cause. So it is with the justified believer. Our good works are not attempts to earn God’s favor, but expressions of the favor we have already received.

This understanding of works as the fruit of justification maintains the delicate balance between grace and responsibility. It affirms that our salvation is entirely of God, while also affirming that this salvation should have visible effects in our lives. It calls us neither to anxious striving nor to complacent inaction, but to a joyful participation in the dance of grace.

Justification and Sanctification: Two Steps in the Same Dance

In the intricate choreography of salvation, justification and sanctification form two distinct yet inseparable movements. In Wesleyan theology, these are not separate events, but two aspects of the same transformative work of grace.

The Apostle Paul, in his first letter to the Corinthians, beautifully encapsulates this dual reality: “And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11). Notice how Paul intertwines these concepts, presenting them not as sequential events but as different facets of the same divine action.

Wesley himself recognized this profound connection, stating, “In the moment we are justified by the grace of God, through the redemption that is in Jesus, we are also born of the Spirit.” This simultaneous occurrence of justification and the beginning of sanctification is a cornerstone of Wesleyan thought.

Imagine, if you will, a coin. On one side is stamped ‘Justification’ – our legal standing before God, declared righteous through faith in Christ. On the other side is stamped ‘Sanctification’ – the ongoing process of becoming in practice what we already are in position. These are two sides of the same coin, inseparable aspects of God’s saving work.

Justification, in this view, is not merely a legal declaration, but the beginning of a transformative relationship. It’s as if God not only declares us fit for the divine dance but also begins to teach us the steps. Sanctification is the lifelong process of learning these steps, of allowing the rhythm of grace to permeate every aspect of our being.

This understanding guards against two dangerous extremes. On one hand, it prevents us from thinking that justification is the end of the story, that once declared righteous, we need not concern ourselves with growing in holiness. On the other hand, it prevents us from falling into the trap of perfectionism, of thinking that our sanctification is what maintains our justified status.

Instead, it presents a dynamic view of the Christian life, where our secure standing before God (justification) propels us into an ever-deepening experience of God’s transforming grace (sanctification). It’s a beautiful dance, where each movement flows into the next, guided by the expert hand of our divine partner.

The Universal Offer: God’s Open Invitation

In the grand ballroom of God’s grace, there is a revolutionary truth that Wesley emphasized with particular vigor: the invitation to this divine dance is universal. The offer of justification, in Wesleyan thought, is extended to all of humanity without discrimination or reservation.

This understanding is rooted in Wesley’s emphasis on prevenient grace – the grace that goes before, that woos and invites before we are even aware of our need. It’s as if God has sent out invitations to His divine dance to every corner of the world, to every human heart.

The Apostle Paul, writing to Titus, captures this universal offer beautifully: “For the grace of God has appeared that offers salvation to all people” (Titus 2:11). Notice the expansive language here – “all people.” Not just the elect, not just the worthy, not just those of a particular nation or ethnicity, but all.

Wesley himself proclaimed with characteristic boldness: “The grace or love of God, whence cometh our salvation, is free in all, and free for all.” This is a staggering claim, one that challenges our human tendencies towards exclusivity and favoritism.

Imagine, if you will, a great banquet hall. At the door stands not a stern bouncer checking names against a list, but the Master of the house Himself, arms spread wide, inviting all who would come. “Come,” He says, “the feast is ready. The dance is about to begin. There’s a place for you.”

This understanding of the universal offer of justification has profound implications. It means that no one is beyond the reach of God’s grace. It means that the most hardened sinner and the most pious saint stand on level ground at the foot of the cross. It means that we can never write off anyone as beyond hope, for God’s invitation knows no bounds.

But let us be clear – while the offer is universal, the acceptance must be individual. God invites all, but forces none. He extends His hand to every person, but each must choose to take it. This preserves human freedom while emphasizing divine grace.

This universal offer also places a great responsibility on those who have accepted the invitation. If God’s grace is indeed “free in all, and free for all,” then we who have experienced it are called to be herald’s of this cosmic invitation. We are to go into the highways and byways, as it were, compelling people to come to the feast, to join the dance.

In a world often marked by division and exclusion, this message of God’s universal invitation stands as a radical affirmation of human worth and divine love. It calls us to see every person we meet as a potential dance partner in God’s grand ballroom, invited by the same grace that has invited us.

The Transformative Power: From Courtroom to Living Room

As we delve deeper into the Wesleyan understanding of justification, we encounter a truth both comforting and challenging: justification is far more than a legal acquittal; it is a profound restoration of relationship. It moves us from the courtroom of divine justice to the living room of divine fellowship.

The Apostle Paul, with his characteristic insight, captures this transformative power: “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here!” (2 Corinthians 5:17). Notice the language of newness, of fundamental change. This is no mere change of status, but a change of nature.

Wesley himself reflected on this dual aspect of justification, stating, “Justification implies a relative change; sanctification, a real one.” But let us not misunderstand – this “relative change” of justification is no less real or significant. It is the change from condemned criminal to beloved child, from distant stranger to intimate friend.

Imagine, if you will, a dilapidated house. Justification is not merely a new sign on the door declaring “This house is sound.” No, it is the beginning of a complete renovation, a restoration that starts the moment we are justified and continues throughout our lives.

This understanding of justification as relationship restoration rather than mere legal acquittal has profound implications. It means that our standing before God is not a cold, impersonal legal status, but a warm, intimate relational reality. We are not merely forgiven, but welcomed. Not just pardoned, but adopted.

Think of the prodigal son in Jesus’ famous parable. When he returns home, his father doesn’t merely cancel his debts and allow him to live as a servant. No, he restores him to full sonship, placing a ring on his finger, sandals on his feet, and throwing a feast in his honor. This is the kind of justification Wesley understood – a justification that doesn’t just clear our record, but welcomes us home.

But let us be clear – this restoration of relationship, while immediate in its initiation, is progressive in its realization. The moment we are justified, we are fully and irrevocably God’s children. Yet growing into the fullness of this relationship, learning to live as beloved sons and daughters, is the work of a lifetime.

This transformative understanding of justification guards against two errors. On one hand, it prevents us from seeing our relationship with God as merely legal or transactional. We are not just pardoned criminals, but beloved children. On the other hand, it reminds us that this restored relationship should have visible effects in our lives. A changed status should lead to a changed life.

In the end, justification in Wesleyan thought is not just about a change of record, but a change of reality. It’s not just about where we stand, but whose we are. It moves us from the cold courtroom of judgment to the warm living room of fellowship, inviting us into an ever-deepening dance with the Divine.

The Ongoing Journey of the Justified

As we draw this exploration to a close, let us remember that in the Wesleyan understanding, justification is not the end of the journey, but its true beginning. It is the moment we step onto the dance floor of grace, but the music plays on, inviting us to ever more complex and beautiful movements.

Wesley himself challenges us: “Faith is the beginning of all good in man, the root of all holiness.” This faith that justifies is also the faith that propels us forward, that keeps us in step with our divine dance partner, that opens our eyes to new vistas of grace and new depths of love.

The justified life, then, is a life of ongoing response to grace. It is a daily choosing to stay on the dance floor, to keep our hand in God’s, to follow His lead even when the steps seem difficult or the rhythm eludes us. It is a continual unwrapping of the gift of righteousness we have in Jesus Christ.

Love, The Downing Family

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.