The following is an excerpt from a book about suffering written by Timothy Downing, Missionary in Ecuador. The book is titled: The Storm Will ComeBuilding Foundations for Inevitable Suffering
Why Suffering Is Mandatory in a Fallen World
The doctrine of the Fall represents one of Christianity’s most profound contributions to human understanding, not merely because it explains the origin of evil but because it establishes the certainty of suffering as an inescapable feature of existence east of Eden. Unlike philosophical systems that treat suffering as an anomaly requiring explanation or therapeutic approaches that view it as a pathology demanding cure, biblical Christianity recognizes suffering as the inevitable consequence of living in a world marked by fundamental discord between divine intention and human reality.
Genesis 3 provides the theological architecture for understanding this inevitability. The entrance of sin into human experience introduces not merely moral corruption but cosmic disruption—a fundamental misalignment between human desire and divine order that manifests itself in every sphere of existence. The ground that was designed to yield its fruit readily now produces thorns and thistles. Childbearing, intended as a source of joy and blessing, becomes attended by pain. Work, originally a means of creative expression and stewardship, becomes toilsome labor. Death, the ultimate contradiction of human aspiration, enters the world as an unwelcome but inescapable reality.
These consequences are not arbitrary punishments imposed by an angry deity but natural results of severed relationship with the source of all life and good. Sin separates human beings not only from God but from themselves, from one another, and from the created order of which they are a part. This separation introduces entropy into every human relationship and project, ensuring that nothing in this present age achieves the perfection for which it was designed or toward which it strives.
The apostle Paul captures this reality in his description of creation itself as subject to “futility” and “bondage to corruption,” groaning in labor pains as it awaits its final redemption (Romans 8:20-22). This cosmic groaning provides the backdrop against which individual human suffering must be understood. We do not suffer as isolated individuals whose particular misfortunes require special explanation, but as participants in a universal condition that affects every created thing.
This universality of suffering serves as both a sobering reality check and a strange comfort. It is sobering because it eliminates the illusion that sufficient wisdom, effort, or faith can insulate us from life’s fundamental difficulties. The most righteous believers, the most intelligent thinkers, and the most powerful rulers all share the common fate of mortality and the common experience of disappointment, loss, and pain. No human achievement, however impressive, can restore the paradise that has been lost or create the perfect world for which we yearn.
Yet this same universality provides comfort by assuring us that our particular sufferings are not evidence of divine disfavor or personal failure but participation in the common lot of humanity. The businessman whose carefully laid plans fail, the mother whose child rebels despite her sacrificial love, the student whose hard work does not yield expected results—all experience not unique tragedies but variations on the universal theme of human limitation in a fallen world.
The doctrine of the Fall also explains why suffering cannot be eliminated through human effort alone, however well-intentioned or technically sophisticated. The sources of our deepest anguish lie not merely in external circumstances that might be altered through social reform or technological advancement but in the fundamental structure of existence in a world estranged from its Creator. Death will come regardless of medical progress. Relationships will disappoint despite psychological insight. Dreams will be deferred or destroyed despite careful planning. The gap between human aspiration and human achievement will persist until the final restoration of all things.
This does not counsel despair but realism—the recognition that the Gospel addresses our condition not by promising to eliminate suffering in this present age but by providing resources for enduring it faithfully and discovering meaning within it. The Christian hope is not for the establishment of heaven on earth through human effort but for the new heavens and new earth that God will create through divine intervention.
The Illusion of Control and the Reality of Contingency
Contemporary Western culture has constructed an elaborate mythology around human control that serves as a psychological defense against the reality of contingency. We are encouraged to believe that the right combination of planning, effort, and positive thinking can insulate us from life’s major disappointments and tragedies. Self-help literature promises techniques for achieving our goals, insurance policies offer protection against financial loss, and medical advances seem to push back the boundaries of mortality itself.
This mythology of control contains enough truth to seem plausible. Human beings do indeed possess significant capacity to shape their circumstances through intelligent action. The farmer who plants in season and tends his crops will generally harvest more than one who neglects these responsibilities. The student who studies diligently will typically perform better than one who does not. The individual who exercises regularly and eats wisely will usually enjoy better health than one who ignores these disciplines.
But the mythology becomes dangerous when it moves from recognizing genuine human agency to assuming comprehensive human control. It encourages the illusion that all significant outcomes can be managed through the proper application of technique, that every problem has a solution, and that every difficulty can be avoided through sufficient wisdom and effort.
This illusion of control manifests itself in various ways within contemporary culture. The business executive who assumes that market forces can be completely predicted and managed discovers that economic systems possess their own logic that transcends individual planning. The parent who believes that the right combination of love, discipline, and educational opportunity can guarantee specific outcomes in their children’s lives learns that human beings possess an irreducible capacity for choice that no external influence can completely determine. The individual who assumes that healthy living guarantees longevity confronts the reality that mortality remains democratically distributed regardless of lifestyle choices.
The therapeutic culture has given this illusion of control a psychological dimension by suggesting that emotional and spiritual suffering can be eliminated through the right combination of insights, techniques, and treatments. While therapy can indeed provide valuable tools for understanding and managing certain kinds of psychological distress, the therapeutic worldview becomes problematic when it promises comprehensive emotional health or suggests that all forms of mental anguish represent pathological conditions rather than normal responses to difficult circumstances.
The prosperity gospel represents the religious version of this same illusion, promising believers that sufficient faith, properly applied, can guarantee health, wealth, and happiness. This theology transforms prayer from communion with God into a technique for controlling divine blessing, and faith from trust in God’s character into confidence in God’s predictability. When life’s inevitable difficulties arise, prosperity theology offers not comfort but condemnation, interpreting suffering as evidence of inadequate faith rather than recognition of human finitude in a fallen world.
The reality that stands behind all these illusions is contingency—the recognition that human life unfolds within a context of factors that lie beyond individual control. The weather patterns that affect agricultural yields, the economic forces that shape employment opportunities, the genetic factors that influence health outcomes, the decisions of other people that affect our own circumstances—all represent forms of contingency that no amount of human planning can completely manage.
Biblical wisdom has always recognized and accounted for this contingency. Proverbs 16:9 observes that “the heart of man plans his way, but the Lord establishes his steps.” James 4:13-15 warns against the presumption of those who say, “Today or tomorrow we will go into such and such a town and spend a year there and trade and make a profit,” without acknowledging that “you do not know what tomorrow will bring” and should instead say, “If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.”
This biblical realism does not counsel passivity or fatalism but rather what might be called “contingent agency”—the recognition that human beings are called to act responsibly within circumstances that they cannot completely control. The farmer still plants and tends his crops, but he acknowledges his dependence upon weather patterns beyond his influence. The student still studies diligently, but she recognizes that health, family circumstances, and a multitude of other factors affect educational outcomes. The businessman still makes careful plans, but he holds those plans lightly, prepared to adapt when circumstances change in unexpected ways.
This acceptance of contingency proves liberating rather than constraining. When we abandon the exhausting effort to control outcomes that lie beyond our influence, we are freed to focus our energies on the things that do fall within our sphere of responsibility. When we cease taking personal credit for every success or personal blame for every failure, we can evaluate our circumstances more accurately and respond more appropriately.
Perhaps most importantly, acceptance of contingency opens space for the recognition of divine providence—the understanding that the factors we cannot control are not merely random but are governed by a wisdom and love that transcend our own. This does not mean that every particular outcome reflects God’s direct intention or that evil somehow serves good purposes, but it does mean that the ultimate trajectory of history remains in divine hands and that our individual stories unfold within that larger narrative of redemption.
Preparing the Soul’s Foundation Before the Winds Blow
The certainty of suffering and the reality of contingency combine to create a moral imperative: we must prepare for trials before they arrive. Just as wise builders construct foundations before erecting walls, and prudent communities prepare for natural disasters before they strike, believers must cultivate spiritual resources before those resources are tested by adversity.
This preparation involves both theological and practical dimensions. Theologically, it requires the development of a worldview that can accommodate suffering without abandoning faith, that can maintain hope in the midst of disappointment, and that can find meaning in experiences that seem to contradict everything we believe about divine love and human dignity.
The doctrinal foundations of Christian faith—creation, fall, redemption, and restoration—provide the intellectual framework necessary for such a worldview. Creation establishes human dignity and purpose, explaining why suffering matters and why we are right to resist it. The Fall explains why suffering is inevitable, preventing us from interpreting its presence as evidence of divine abandonment or personal failure. Redemption reveals how suffering can serve constructive purposes, showing how God can bring good from evil without being responsible for evil. The promise of restoration maintains hope for ultimate resolution while acknowledging that such resolution may not occur within the boundaries of this present age.
But intellectual understanding alone proves insufficient when trials actually arrive. The man whose child is killed in an accident does not need better theological arguments but deeper spiritual resources. The woman whose marriage fails despite her best efforts requires not more sophisticated analysis but greater emotional resilience. The believer facing terminal illness needs not additional doctrinal information but more profound trust in God’s character.
This is why spiritual preparation must involve not merely the accumulation of knowledge but the cultivation of practices that build character and strengthen faith. The classical Christian disciplines—prayer, Scripture meditation, corporate worship, fasting, confession, and service—serve as training exercises for the soul, building the spiritual muscles that will be required when life’s inevitable storms arrive.
Prayer, properly understood, is not primarily a technique for obtaining desired outcomes but a practice of communion with God that gradually reshapes our desires to align with divine purposes. The believer who has spent years learning to say “Thy will be done” in small matters will be better equipped to say it when confronted with major tragedies. The individual who has practiced bringing both gratitude and complaint to God in daily prayer will possess the vocabulary necessary for maintaining relationship with God when that relationship is tested by difficult circumstances.
Scripture meditation serves similar preparatory purposes by filling the mind with truth that can sustain faith when experience seems to contradict it. The believer whose imagination has been shaped by the stories of faithful men and women who endured trials throughout biblical history will recognize patterns of divine faithfulness that transcend immediate circumstances. The individual who has internalized the promises of Scripture will have resources to draw upon when those promises are the only things standing between faith and despair.
Corporate worship provides the communal dimension of preparation, reminding believers that they are part of a larger story that transcends their individual experiences. The congregation that regularly confesses its sins together, recites its faith together, and participates in the sacraments together builds bonds of mutual support that can sustain individual members when they face particular trials. The community that practices bearing one another’s burdens in small matters will be better equipped to provide meaningful support when those burdens become overwhelming.
The discipline of fasting serves as particularly valuable preparation for involuntary deprivation. The believer who has learned to find spiritual satisfaction in the temporary abandonment of physical pleasure will be better prepared to maintain spiritual equilibrium when pleasure is removed by circumstances beyond his control. The individual who has practiced saying no to legitimate desires will possess greater resources for accepting the much more difficult no that suffering sometimes requires.
Confession and forgiveness prepare the soul for the guilt and resentment that often accompany significant trials. The believer who has learned to acknowledge his own failures honestly and to extend forgiveness to others readily will be better equipped to resist the spiral of self-condemnation and blame that can transform mere suffering into genuine despair. The individual who has practiced receiving divine forgiveness for past failures will be more likely to trust divine mercy in future difficulties.
Service to others provides perhaps the most important form of preparation by developing the outward focus that can preserve sanity when inward focus becomes unbearable. The believer who has cultivated habits of attention to others’ needs will possess alternative sources of meaning and purpose when his own desires are frustrated. The individual who has learned to find joy in contributing to others’ welfare will retain reasons for gratitude even when personal circumstances provide little cause for satisfaction.
All of these disciplines work together to build what might be called “spiritual capital”—resources of faith, hope, and love that can be drawn upon when they are most needed. Like financial capital, spiritual capital must be accumulated during seasons of plenty if it is to be available during seasons of want. The believer who waits until crisis arrives to begin developing spiritual resources will discover that such resources cannot be created instantly but require patient cultivation over time.
This preparation does not guarantee immunity from suffering or even from the emotional and spiritual struggles that suffering brings. The most spiritually mature believers still experience grief, disappointment, fear, and doubt when confronted with life’s major trials. But spiritual preparation does provide resources for working through these experiences constructively rather than being overwhelmed by them destructively.
The ultimate goal of such preparation is not the elimination of suffering but the development of character that can bear suffering faithfully. This represents a fundamentally different approach from our culture’s focus on avoiding or minimizing difficulty. Instead of asking how we can escape life’s storms, we ask how we can build foundations strong enough to withstand them. Instead of seeking techniques for controlling circumstances, we cultivate practices that strengthen our capacity to respond faithfully regardless of circumstances.
Such an approach requires a fundamental reorientation of priorities and expectations. It means investing more energy in character development than circumstance management, more attention to spiritual disciplines than secular strategies, more focus on eternal perspectives than temporal outcomes. It represents, in short, a return to the ancient Christian understanding that the goal of human existence is not the maximization of pleasure or the minimization of pain but the formation of souls capable of loving God and neighbor regardless of external conditions.
The storm will come—this much is certain. The question that remains is whether it will find us with foundations adequate to withstand its force, or whether we will discover too late that we have built our lives upon sand. The choice, while it remains ours to make, cannot be postponed indefinitely. The time for building wisely is now, while the sun still shines and the winds remain calm. Tomorrow may bring the storm, and tomorrow may be too late.
We’re delighted to share this book with you one post at a time. If you’d prefer to hold this book in your hands—there’s something beautiful about turning actual pages as you study God’s Word—you can easily order a physical copy from Amazon by simply clicking on the book image above.
