The Real Enemy Is Closer Than You Think

Let us speak plainly about the world outside.

There are forces at work in the landscape of Western civilization that are not friendly to the Christian faith, and they deserve to be named with the specificity that the idol of niceness has long denied them.

Islam does not distinguish between the sacred and the political, it has demonstrated across centuries and continents and in present-tense headlines its vision for the ordering of society—a vision in which women are property with theological justifications, in which apostasy is executable, in which the submission demanded is not the metaphorical surrender of the heart but the literal subjugation of the body, the law, the street, the classroom, and the state. This is not an extremist fringe to be carefully distinguished from the authentic tradition. It is a strand woven through the dark tradition with the full weight of historical authority behind it, and to pretend otherwise is not tolerance. It is a lie dressed in the borrowed clothing of academic nuance.

Secular nihilism that has achieved what no tyrant in history could manage through violence: the voluntary surrender of meaning by people who have everything. It has built its temples in the streaming services, in the pornography that now flows into the bedrooms of twelve-year-olds with the casual ease of turning on a faucet, in the pharmaceutical management of a despair so widespread we have stopped questioning its causes and begun simply medicating its symptoms. It has produced a generation that cannot tell you why they exist, cannot defend the proposition that anything is worth dying for, and cannot imagine a form of authority that is not simply the imposition of one group’s preferences over another’s—because they have been taught, with great diligence, that there is no truth above preference.

There are spiritual traditions that do not worship the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, that offer their practitioners an encounter with forces the Bible does not hesitate to name as demonic, and that have found in the spiritual hunger of post-Christian Westerners a market of remarkable receptivity. The crystals and the horoscopes are not quaint eccentricities. They are the symptomatic expression of a culture that has lost its true north and is reaching, with the desperation of the genuinely lost, for anything that might orient it.

Name these things. Do not flinch from them. Do not qualify them into comfortable abstraction. The prophets didn’t, and neither did the apostles, and the saints who built Christendom from the ruins of a pagan empire did not earn that civilization by carefully acknowledging the complexity of Molech worship before getting to their gentle concerns about child sacrifice.

But here is the thing that will cost you something to hear.

None of these external threats is what broke us.

They are real. They are serious. They deserve the unflinching engagement that the church of the last half-century has largely declined to give them. But they are not the decisive failure. They are not the wound that will kill us. They are the infection that entered through a wound we made ourselves, and if you want to understand how we got here, you must be willing to turn from the horizon where the enemies gather and face, instead, the sanctuary where the betrayal happened.

The decisive failure is internal.

It lives in the pulpit. It lives in the denominational headquarters. It lives in the seminary classroom where a generation of ministers was trained to view the prophetic tradition as a communication challenge rather than a divine commission. It lives in the small group curriculum that has replaced conviction with conversation, that has decided the highest goal of Christian community is that everyone leaves feeling heard, regardless of whether anyone leaves having encountered truth.

It lives in the Christian who has decided, after careful and prolonged consideration, that God is simply too harsh.

This is the creature that haunts every chapter of this book, and it deserves a proper introduction.

The nicer-than-God Christian is not a rare specimen. He is the dominant species in the contemporary Western church, so thoroughly successful in his adaptation to the surrounding culture that he has ceased to notice the adaptation occurred. He attends faithfully. He serves generously. He speaks warmly of Jesus with a fluency that conceals how rarely he has encountered the actual Jesus of the actual Scriptures, as opposed to the therapeutic mascot his tradition has handed him.

He cannot read the story of Ananias and Sapphira—struck dead at the apostle’s feet for lying to the Holy Spirit—without feeling that something has gone wrong, that this doesn’t square with the God he has been told about, that perhaps this passage requires careful contextualizing. He reads the conquest narratives of Joshua with the discomfort of a man encountering something embarrassing at a formal dinner. He processes the wrath of God as a theological embarrassment to be managed rather than a revelation of holiness to be feared and worshiped. He has, in short, decided that he is more merciful than the Almighty—that if he were running things, he would have done it rather differently, with less fire, less judgment, less of that uncomfortable exclusivity about the Way and the Truth and the Life.

And so he has constructed, with great care and genuine sincerity, a God who agrees with him. A God who shares his discomfort with confrontation. A God who appreciates nuance. A God who, above all, would never want anyone to feel unwelcome.

This God is an idol. It wears the Name, but it is an idol—a projection of postmodern therapeutic sensibility onto the face of the living God, who is in fact consuming fire, whose holiness is not a soft thing, whose love is not a permissive thing, and whose patience with our construction of manageable deities has never, in the full sweep of redemptive history, been without limit.

The nicer-than-God Christian is not the solution to the church’s crisis. He is the church’s crisis. He is the locked door through which no recovery can pass. Because as long as the primary obstacle to prophetic Christianity within the church is not the secular progressive outside it but the sentimental Christian inside it—the one who will call you unloving the moment you name a sin, the one who will accuse you of lacking grace the moment you refuse to endorse what God has condemned—the reformation cannot begin.

He must be confronted. Gently, yes—with patience, with love, with the pastoral care that the moment requires—but confronted nonetheless. Because the kindest thing you can do for a man who is dying of a curable disease is to tell him he is dying, even if the telling is unwelcome.

The external enemies are gathering. They have been gathering for a generation, and they have been gathering at the speed that vacuums allow, filling the space that a retreating church left behind. Every pulpit that went silent on sexuality created space for another voice. Every denomination that decided human sexuality was too divisive to address clearly planted another seed of the confusion that now grows unchecked in the culture. Every Christian institution that decided its survival required the approval of the surrounding culture surrendered, in that decision, the only thing that made its survival worth fighting for.

But the vacuum was created from inside. The retreat was chosen, freely, by people who had the Word of God in their hands and decided it was too sharp for public use.

You cannot blame the water for flooding the valley. You must ask who breached the dam.

The dam was breached by niceness—by the slow, deliberate, applauded erosion of prophetic courage in the name of accessibility, relevance, inclusion, and the particular variety of cowardice that our age has chosen to call compassion.

The enemy is closer than you think.

He is in the mirror. He is in the pulpit. He is in the room where the elders meet and decide, again, that now is not the right time for the hard conversation—and it is never the right time, it is always almost the right time, it is perpetually the season of one more careful preparation before the confrontation that will never come.

The kingdom of God has never been built by men waiting for the right time to be brave.

Two people pose in front of a colorful map of Ecuador.
Blessings, the Downing family

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.